Cloud AI or local AI: the right choice for your data

You get a decision guide on which tasks a cloud service can take on, what requires a language model on your own hardware and when a combination of both is worthwhile.

Discussion about documents on a clipboard

Not all information belongs in the cloud

Cloud services such as Microsoft 365 Copilot, ChatGPT or Claude provide very powerful models without you needing your own hardware. Your inputs are processed in the provider's data centres, depending on the provider and plan also outside the EU.

A locally operated language model processes inputs and documents in your own network. In return, you are responsible for the hardware, operation and updates, and the models do not match the performance of the largest cloud models for every task. The decision therefore depends on which data you process and which tasks the AI is to take on.

Cloud AI and local AI compared

CriterionCloud AILocal AI
Confidentialityprocessing by the provider, terms depending on plan and contractprocessing in your own network, inputs and documents do not leave the company
Model performanceaccess to the largest current modelsdepends on hardware and model, often sufficient for clearly defined tasks such as questions about internal documents
Start and effortready to go quickly, no hardware of your ownpurchase, set-up and ongoing operation of the hardware
Costs over the lifetimeongoing costs per user or based on usageinvestment in hardware and ongoing operation, largely independent of the number of requests
Dependence on the providerthe provider determines models, plans and termsyou decide on the models and the timing of changes yourself
External connectioninternet connection requiredcan be used in your own network even without an external connection
Evidencecontracts and evidence from the provideryour own documentation and controls
The table shows typical differences. Which solution suits you depends on your data, tasks and requirements.

How your decision is reached

  • Collecting use cases Together with your specialist departments, it is recorded what AI is to be used for and which data it needs to work with for this.
  • Classifying data You define which information may go into cloud services, which is only processed locally and which does not belong in AI systems at all.
  • Reviewing requirements Legal and contractual requirements are taken into account, for example from NIS-2, from professional secrecy obligations or from contracts with your customers.
  • Evaluating providers and models Cloud plans and local models are compared by storage location, contract terms and suitability for your tasks.
  • Costs over the lifetime You see the ongoing costs of the cloud plans side by side with the investment in and operation of a local solution.
  • Recommendation with next steps You get a recommendation for cloud, local or a combination, with a proposal for the first pilot.

For classified information, we do not make a general statement about the suitability of an AI solution. A case-by-case review is required here, more on this on the VS-NfD page.

For critical infrastructure (KRITIS) and security-sensitive companies

Operators of critical facilities, the healthcare sector, law firms and public institutions work with data whose leakage would have serious consequences. Among other things, NIS-2 requires risks in the supply chain to be taken into account, and this also includes cloud services for AI.

For these companies, a combination often makes sense: general tasks such as help with wording run on a reviewed cloud plan, while confidential documents are processed by a local AI server in-house.

Related topics

Frequently asked questions about cloud AI and local AI

Is local AI automatically more secure?

Not automatically. Although your data stays in your own network, security depends on how the system is operated: with current updates, clean permissions, logging and backup. A poorly maintained local server can be a greater risk than a reviewed cloud plan.

Can we combine cloud AI and local AI?

Yes, and this is often exactly the right solution. What matters are clear rules on which data belongs in which system, set out in your AI policy.

Is a local model sufficient for our tasks?

That depends on the task. For clearly defined tasks such as questions about internal documents, a local model is often sufficient, while for very demanding tasks the large cloud models are usually superior. A pilot with your own tasks shows whether the quality is sufficient.

May we process classified information with AI?

We do not make a general statement on this. Classified information is subject to special requirements for products and operation, which must be reviewed case by case. You can find information on handling classified information in IT on the VS-NfD page.