SOC 2 attestation: what the report tells you about your IT service provider

Anyone who entrusts servers, data or the operation of their IT to a service provider must be able to assess the security measures of that provider. In tenders and supplier assessments, a SOC 2 report is frequently requested for this purpose. This article explains what such an attestation says, how it differs from other forms of evidence and how to read a report effectively.

What SOC 2 is

SOC stands for System and Organization Controls. Behind it is a series of examination services whose standards are set by the US professional association of certified public accountants, the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants (AICPA). A SOC 2 report describes the system of a service provider and the controls it uses to protect the information of its customers. An independent audit firm assesses whether this description is accurate and whether the controls are suitable.

In German, this is usually referred to as a “Testat”, an attestation, rather than a certificate. There is no simple “pass” or “fail”. You receive a detailed report with the opinion of the auditors, the system description of the service provider and, depending on the type of report, the tests performed and their results.

The Trust Services Criteria

The benchmark for the examination is the AICPA Trust Services Criteria. They are divided into five categories:

  • Security: Protection of systems and information against unauthorised access and misuse. This category is part of every SOC 2 examination.
  • Availability: The systems are available as agreed.
  • Processing Integrity: Data is processed completely, correctly and in a timely manner.
  • Confidentiality: Information classified as confidential is protected.
  • Privacy: Personal data is collected, used and deleted in accordance with defined principles.

The service provider decides which categories are examined in addition to security. You should therefore check whether the categories that are important to you are included in the report.

Type 1 and Type 2

SOC 2 reports come in two types, often also referred to as Type I and Type II:

  • Type 1: The auditors assess, as of a specific date, whether the system description is accurate and whether the controls are appropriately designed. Whether they are actually complied with in everyday operation is not part of the examination.
  • Type 2: The auditors additionally assess whether the controls were effective over a period of time, often several months up to one year. To do this, they test samples, for example whether the accounts of employees who have left were actually disabled.

A Type 1 report is often the first step. A Type 2 report is more meaningful for your assessment, because it shows that the controls were complied with over a longer period.

How it differs from ISO/IEC 27001 and BSI C5

ISO/IEC 27001 is an international standard published by ISO and IEC. It sets out the requirements for an information security management system (ISMS), i.e. for how a company systematically identifies risks to its information, treats them and continually improves. Certification is carried out by an accredited certification body, not by ISO itself. You receive a certificate stating the audited scope. It confirms that the management system conforms to the standard. It does not contain individual controls or audit results.

BSI C5, the Cloud Computing Compliance Criteria Catalogue of the German Federal Office for Information Security (BSI), sets out minimum requirements for secure cloud computing and is aimed primarily at cloud providers. As with SOC 2, auditors carry out the examination and prepare a report. Depending on the type of examination, here too the assessment is made either only as of a specific date or additionally over a period of time. In Germany, C5 is frequently required for cloud services, for example in the healthcare sector.

These forms of evidence are not mutually exclusive, they answer different questions. ISO/IEC 27001 shows that information security is managed systematically in the company. SOC 2 and C5 show in detail which controls a service provider has put in place and with what result they were examined.

What to look out for with your IT service provider

  • Request the report: Ask for the complete report, not just a logo or a brief confirmation. SOC 2 reports are not public and are usually shared subject to a non-disclosure agreement. The public SOC 3 report is a summary without details of the tests performed.
  • Check the type and period: Is it a Type 1 or Type 2 report, and which period was examined? If the end of the examination period was a long time ago, the report says little about the current situation. In that case, ask for the follow-up report or for written confirmation that nothing material has changed since then.
  • Check the scope: Which services, locations and systems are covered, and which of the five categories? The report should cover exactly the service you use. If subcontractors provide parts of the service, such as operating the data centre, and these are excluded from the examination, you need separate evidence for them.
  • Read the exceptions: In a Type 2 report, the auditors document deviations they found during their tests. Individual deviations are not unusual. What matters is how serious they are and how the service provider has responded to them. Also check whether the audit opinion is qualified.
  • Note your own obligations: Many reports list complementary controls that are the responsibility of the customer, such as maintaining your own user accounts. You implement these yourself so that the controls of the service provider are effective.
  • Identify the auditor: The report should clearly come from an independent audit firm that is named in it and has signed the audit opinion.

A SOC 2 report does not replace your own assessment. However, it gives you an audited basis on which to base your supplier assessment and with which you can ask targeted questions.

The status at conpro IT

conpro IT is currently preparing for a SOC 2 attestation. You can find out which documents are already available to you today, such as the technical and organisational measures and the data processing agreement, on the Security and assurance page. The IT security and compliance page describes how we protect the systems and data of our customers.

Sources

IT security and compliance

You get protective measures that suit your business and, on request, the documents you need for your supplier assessment.